Comparative Pharmacodynamics of Three Different Botulinum Toxin Type A Preparations following Repeated Intramuscular Administration in Mice.
초록 펼치기
Botulinum toxin (BT) is used therapeutically since the late 1980s. For many years, BT drugs were provided by a small group of manufacturers from Europe and the United States. As BT's use for aesthetic purposes surged, numerous new manufacturers entered the field, particularly from Korea. We want to give an overview about the rapidly expanding and diversifying BT landscape in Korea. Altogether, there are 15 Korean manufacturers of 19 BT drugs registered in Korea, mainly for aesthetic indications. There are 2 Class 1 drugs from 2 Korean manufacturers registered in Korea for export, domestic use and registered in the USA and Europe. These are PrabotulinumtoxinA (Daewoong/Evolus) and LetibotulinumtoxinA (Hugel/Croma Pharma). There are 12 Class 2 drugs from 10 Korean manufacturers registered in Korea for export and domestic use, including Neuronox®, the first Korean BT drug registered in 2006, NivobotulinumtoxinA/Innotox®, the world-wide first liquid BT type A preparation and Coretox®, the world-wide second BT drug without complexing proteins. Innotox® and Toxsta® are currently performing clinical studies in the USA. Additionally, there are 5 Class 3 BT drugs from 5 Korean manufacturers registered in Korea for export use only. 5 Korean manufacturers have 5 drug projects in Korea in advanced development phases. With this, Korea is now the country with the worldwide largest number of BT manufacturers and BT drugs. Gastric botulinum toxin therapy is gaining attention as a non-invasive treatment for obesity. However, existing studies show inconsistent results and standardized protocols remain lacking. We aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of a novel whole-stomach injection method emphasizing the antrum and fundus in obese patients in Japan. A total of 144 obese patients (mean age 42.3 years, mean BMI 30.3 kg/m²) underwent gastric botulinum toxin therapy at our institution between February 2023 and November 2024. Coretox (300-400 U) was injected endoscopically across the entire stomach, with increased concentration in the antrum and fundus. Patients were followed for six months post procedure. The primary outcome was the percentage of total body weight loss (%TBWL), and safety was assessed by the occurrence of complications per Clavien-Dindo classification. Mean %TBWL was 6.5% at one month, 10.2% at three months, and 12.2% at six months post treatment. No complications or adverse events were reported. The average procedure time was 5.7 minutes, and all patients completed follow-up as scheduled. We hypothesize that the observed efficacy may be partially attributed to our refined injection technique and individualized BMI-based dosage adjustment, although further controlled studies are needed to validate this approach. Gastric botulinum therapy using a novel full-stomach injection method focusing on the antrum and fundus was found to be both safe and effective in a Japanese obese population. This technique may offer a promising, minimally invasive option for obesity management. Further multicenter and long-term studies are warranted to validate and standardize this approach. The formation of neutralizing antibodies is a growing concern in the use of botulinum neurotoxin A (BoNT/A) as it may result in secondary treatment failure. Differences in the immunogenicity of BoNT/A formulations have been attributed to the presence of pharmacologically unnecessary bacterial components. Reportedly, the rate of antibody-mediated secondary non-response is lowest in complexing protein-free (CF) IncobotulinumtoxinA (INCO). Here, the published data and literature on the composition and properties of the three commercially available CF-BoNT/A formulations, namely, INCO, Coretox® (CORE), and DaxibotulinumtoxinA (DAXI), are reviewed to elucidate the implications for their potential immunogenicity. While all three BoNT/A formulations are free of complexing proteins and contain the core BoNT/A molecule as the active pharmaceutical ingredient, they differ in their production protocols and excipients, which may affect their immunogenicity. INCO contains only two immunologically inconspicuous excipients, namely, human serum albumin and sucrose, and has demonstrated low immunogenicity in daily practice and clinical studies for more than ten years. DAXI contains four excipients, namely, L-histidine, trehalosedihydrate, polysorbate 20, and the highly charged RTP004 peptide, of which the latter two may increase the immunogenicity of BoNT/A by introducing neo-epitopes. In early clinical studies with DAXI, antibodies against BoNT/A and RTP004 were found at low frequencies; however, the follow-up period was critically short, with a maximum of three injections. CORE contains four excipients: L-methionine, sucrose, NaCl, and polysorbate 20. Presently, no data are available on the immunogenicity of CORE in human beings. It remains to be seen whether all three CF BoNT/A formulations demonstrate the same low immunogenicity in patients over a long period of time. Botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT/A) causes muscle paralysis by blocking cholinergic signaling at neuromuscular junctions and is widely used to temporarily correct spasticity-related disorders and deformities. The paralytic effects of BoNT/A are time-limited and require repeated injections at regular intervals to achieve long-term therapeutic benefits. Differences in the level and duration of effectivity among various BoNT/A products can be attributed to their unique manufacturing processes, formulation, and noninterchangeable potency units. Herein, we compared the pharmacodynamics of three BoNT/A formulations, i.e., Botox® (onabotulinumtoxinA), Xeomin® (incobotulinumtoxinA), and Coretox®, following repeated intramuscular (IM) injections in mice. Three IM injections of BoNT/A formulations (12 U/kg per dose), 12-weeks apart, were administered at the right gastrocnemius. Local paresis and chemodenervation efficacy were evaluated over 36 weeks using the digit abduction score (DAS) and compound muscle action potential (CMAP), respectively. One week after administration, all three BoNT/A formulations induced peak DAS and maximal reduction of CMAP amplitudes. Among the three BoNT/A formulations, only Coretox® afforded a significant increase in paretic effects and chemodenervation with a prolonged duration of action after repeated injections. These findings suggest that Coretox® may offer a better overall therapeutic performance in clinical settings. Human serum albumin (HSA) has been widely used as a pharmaceutical excipient in Botulinum toxin serotype A (BoNT/A) products that are indicated for use in therapeutics and cosmetics. However, HSA as a human-derived material has some concerns, such as the potential risk of transmission of infectious agents, an insufficient supply, and difficulty in maintaining a certain quality. For those reasons, newly developed BoNT/A products (CORETOX®, Medytox, Inc., Republic of Korea) contained polysorbate 20, a non-human-derived excipient, to replace the HSA. However, most safety studies of polysorbate 20 have been conducted with non-invasive routes of administration, and thus there are a few studies on the safety of polysorbate 20 when administered intramuscularly. To secure the in vivo safety profile of polysorbate 20, a four-week repeated intramuscular dose toxicity study (0.02, 0.1, and 0.4 mg/kg, one injection every two weeks for a total of three injections) was conducted in 66 Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats. An intradermal irritation study was further conducted with 18 New Zealand White (NZW) rabbits. The toxicological evaluation of HSA (0.06 and 0.12 mg/kg) was also carried out as a comparative substance. Systemic and local toxicities were not observed in any of the SD rats or NZW rabbits based on clinical signs, body weight, hematology, clinical biochemistry, macroscopic findings on necropsy, histopathology of the injection site, and alle